What Was the 1776 Commission — and Why Did It Spark So Much Debate?

What Was the 1776 Commission — and Why Did It Spark So Much Debate?

If you’ve ever heard the term 1776 Commission and wondered what all the fuss was about, you’re not alone. This wasn’t just another task force lost in the shuffle of Washington — it was a presidential advisory committee with a very specific mission: reshape how America tells its own story.

The Basics: What Was the 1776 Commission?

The 1776 Commission was established by former President Donald Trump in late 2020. It came as a response to what he and some conservatives saw as an “unpatriotic” trend in American education — especially criticism of the country’s history with slavery and racism.

The commission's stated goal was to promote a “patriotic education,” rooted in the founding ideals of the United States — life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. The name 1776 itself was a clear reference to the American Revolution, designed as a sort of counterpoint to The 1619 Project by The New York Times, which focused on how slavery shaped the nation’s founding and development.

So, Why the Controversy?

The 1776 Commission wasn’t around long — just two months, give or take — but its final report, released in January 2021, caused a storm. Critics argued that the document:

  • Glossed over or downplayed the role of slavery and systemic racism in U.S. history.
  • Painted a simplistic, almost mythological version of American history.
  • Ignored modern scholarly consensus on complex historical issues.

Even some historians labeled the report as more ideological than educational, claiming it resembled political propaganda rather than academic research. Within hours of taking office, President Joe Biden signed an executive order dissolving the commission, calling for a return to fact-based historical education.

Why Does It Still Matter?

Even though the commission was short-lived, the conversation it ignited hasn’t gone anywhere. The fight over how history is taught — especially around race, civil rights, and the nation’s founding — is now front and center in debates about school curriculums, library books, and even state laws.

Supporters of the commission believed it could strengthen national pride and unity by emphasizing the country’s ideals. Critics argued that true patriotism requires an honest reckoning with both the country’s achievements and its failures.

Want to Learn More? Here Are Some Helpful Sources:

The bottom line?

How we teach history shapes not just what kids know — but how they see the world. Whether you lean toward the ideals of the 1776 Commission or the critiques from historians, this conversation is far from over.


Back to blog